As a small business owner, you’re constantly looking for new ways to market your products and services. And in the online world, list mailers and safelists seem to pop up everywhere as “easy” and “cheap” marketing solutions.
But do they actually deliver results? Or are they just a waste of time and money?
Let’s take a closer look at how list mailers work, their pros and cons, and whether there’s a way to make them effective for small business marketing.
Contents
What Are List Mailers, and How Do They Work?
A list mailer or safelist is essentially a permission-based community of people who have agreed to receive emails from other members in exchange for the ability to send emails to the rest of the group themselves.
There are usually different membership levels, with free accounts that allow you to send a limited number of emails and paid accounts with higher sending limits and other benefits. The idea is that by paying to be a member, you gain access to promote your business to a targeted audience of subscribers who are open to receiving marketing emails.
On the surface, it seems like an easy way to reach potential customers without spending a fortune like you would on traditional advertising. But there are a few problems with the standard list mailer structure that make it less beneficial than it appears.
The Biggest Pitfalls of Traditional List Mailers
One of the biggest issues with typical list mailers and safelists is that it often creates a situation where businesses and marketers with very limited budgets are promoting to an audience that also has very little income or ability to buy. Essentially, people with no money are advertising to people with no money!
Because anyone can join for free, there is little financial barrier to entry. And the audience is usually made up primarily of newbies to online marketing and small business owners participating to build their own customer bases. They’re not necessarily looking to purchase from other members.
This dynamic drives down the quality of the potential leads and customers you can gain access to as a paying member. And it makes it difficult to generate much return on your investment since the audience isn’t monetizable.
Another problem is that membership prices are often set arbitrarily without correlating to the actual size or value of the list itself. Prices are based on what the owner thinks can be charged, rather than what membership is really worth.
For example, a brand new safelist with only 100 subscribers may charge $10 or $20 per month for upgraded “Gold” member status. But with such a tiny list, that price point isn’t actually justified based on the potential return.
This means early adopters and first-paying members take on a much higher risk by shelling out cash to be promoted to an unproven and underdeveloped audience. Yet they receive no discount or incentive for joining early before the list value has actually been established.
The lack of fair pricing makes it hard for serious businesses to take advantage of list mailers strategically over the long-term. There’s little loyalty or reason to stick around if you joined as a founding paid member but are now being charged higher rates despite minimal list growth.
Turning List Mailers Into Effective Marketing Tools
While traditional list mailers have some clear issues, there are ways to improve the model to boost results and make them beneficial for entrepreneurs and small business owners on a budget.
The primary keys are establishing fair pricing correlated to real list value and building in incentives that reward member activity and increase genuine engagement.
Dynamic Pricing Based on Real Value
Instead of arbitrarily setting prices, take a dynamic pricing approach. Make paid membership rates increase incrementally in correlation with the number of active paid subscribers.
For example, the first 25 paid members could be just $5 per month. Rates gradually increase to $10 per month at 50 members, $15 at 75 members, and so on.
This way, value aligns perfectly with price. Early adopters take on minimal risk by joining when the list is unproven, but are rewarded with the lowest lifetime membership rates as the community grows. Fair pricing sustains growth and loyalty.
Activity-Based Participation Incentives
To address the problem of unengaged members simply spamming the list rather than interacting, make privileges contingent on giving value first.
Set a requirement that to earn 1 email credit to send your promos, you must first click and engage with a few emails from other members. This ensures each person is contributing value back to the community.
When your paying members have financial skin in the game AND they’re incentivized to be active, organic engagement and quality will rise. Now you’ve got a model optimized for results.
Taking It a Step Further with Dynamic Safelists
A brilliant example of a list mailer using this improved, value-driven dynamic pricing model is Mailer.Gold – the world’s first dynamically priced safelist.
Created by industry experts Frank Bauer and Clinton Clark, Mailer.Gold addresses the key weaknesses holding traditional list mailers back from being truly effective for small businesses.
Early adopters are rewarded with the lowest prices. Rates start as low as $8 and increment by just $.01 cent with each new paid member that joins. You lock in ultra-low membership rates for life by joining early.
And to send emails, members must first click on and engage with 5 emails from other members for 10 seconds each. Just 1 minute of your time earns the Privilege of reaching the paid audience.
By aligning pricing with real value as the list grows, and building in activity incentives, Mailer.Gold has cracked the code on making safelists a viable growth channel for entrepreneurs.
The Power of List Mailers
While typical list mailers and safelists have some inherent flaws, the concept is sound. And with improvements to pricing models and engagement incentives, the approach can drive results.
Fair dynamic pricing ensures value is tied directly to cost at all times. Activity requirements encourage quality participation. And the numbers game probability works in your favor the larger the serious audience gets.
Platforms like Mailer.Gold show the potential of list mailers to become true drivers of customer growth. By joining early as a paid member, small businesses can leverage the model to access engaged audiences and amplify their marketing at extremely affordable rates.
Rather than write off safelists as ineffective, take a closer look at ones built the right way.
Join my recommended option, Mailer.Gold to unlock the true benefits of this approach for your business: https://mailer.gold/myonlineavenue
When done right, list mailers provide real opportunities for entrepreneurs and small businesses that can’t rely on expensive traditional advertising. The curious case is closed; with the proper structure, list mailers can work and deliver results.